2027 intake — now booking · MMI & Panel Interview Course + Mock Interview · Book your spot →
Interview · 2027 Entry

Medical Ethics at Interview — 10 Scenarios Every Applicant Should Practise

Medical ethics is a near-guaranteed MMI station. Every scenario below is drawn from recent UK interviews. Each gets a structured 4-pillar answer — the framework examiners mark against.

The framework — 4 pillars of medical ethics

  1. Autonomy — the patient's right to make their own decisions.
  2. Beneficence — the duty to do good for the patient.
  3. Non-maleficence — the duty to avoid harm.
  4. Justice — fair distribution of resources and equal treatment.

Every answer should name the dilemma, apply each relevant pillar, acknowledge the trade-off, and give a reasoned conclusion. Avoid absolute positions.

Scenario 1: Confidentiality vs safeguarding

A 15-year-old girl asks you for contraception but does not want her parents to know.

Answer structure: Autonomy supports her right to make decisions about her own body; beneficence supports providing contraception to prevent unintended pregnancy; non-maleficence raises concern about underlying safeguarding (is the partner adult? is there coercion?). Apply Gillick/Fraser guidelines: assess her maturity to understand the decision, encourage parental involvement, confirm no safeguarding issue, then prescribe if appropriate. Conclude: autonomy and beneficence prevail if Fraser criteria are met.

Scenario 2: Patient refusing life-saving treatment

A Jehovah's Witness refuses a blood transfusion that would save their life.

Answer: Autonomy allows a competent adult to refuse any treatment, even if refusal leads to death. Beneficence and non-maleficence would normally support the transfusion. Check capacity (does the patient understand the consequences?) and explore alternatives (cell salvage, iron therapy). If capacity is intact, you must respect the refusal. Record a clear advance directive. Conclude: autonomy wins when capacity is confirmed.

Scenario 3: Funding expensive drugs

Should the NHS fund a £300,000 cancer drug that extends life by 3 months on average?

Answer: Justice (opportunity cost — what else could £300,000 fund?) competes with beneficence for the individual patient. NICE uses QALYs (quality-adjusted life years) to decide. Consider: the drug's side-effect profile may reduce quality of life, making the 3 months less valuable; by contrast, early palliative care may cost less and improve the same outcomes. Conclude: justice-based rationing is defensible but should include patient voice and transparent criteria.

Scenario 4: The lying doctor

Is it ever right for a doctor to lie to a patient?

Answer: Honesty supports autonomy (patients need truth to make decisions) and the doctor-patient relationship. Lying is rarely justifiable. Exception: "therapeutic privilege" — withholding information that would cause serious psychological harm, defined narrowly. Timing of disclosure can be adjusted; the content should not be falsified. Conclude: not lying, but the manner and timing of truth-telling is a judgement call.

Scenario 5: The impaired colleague

A senior colleague is drinking before shifts. What do you do?

Answer: Non-maleficence to patients is paramount. Speak with the colleague directly first, offer support (occupational health). If no change, or if patients are at immediate risk, escalate to a senior / GMC. Justice to patients overrides loyalty to the colleague. Conclude: patient safety requires escalation even when it's personally uncomfortable.

Scenario 6: Striking doctors

Should doctors be allowed to strike?

Answer: Argument for: justice (fair pay for essential work) attracts talent and sustains the workforce; a sustainable NHS requires fair employment. Argument against: non-maleficence to patients harmed by cancelled operations; concerns about the duty of care overriding industrial rights. Compromise: emergency and life-saving care continues; non-urgent is deferred. Conclude: strikes are defensible as a last resort with safeguards for emergency care.

Scenario 7: Organ allocation

You have one liver and three patients who need it. How do you decide?

Answer: Justice demands fair criteria. Factors: medical need (sickest first?), likelihood of success (best outcome?), waiting time (first come first served?), lifestyle factors (controversial — is a transplant withheld from someone who drinks?). UK transplant policy uses a composite score. Conclude: a transparent formula combining need and outcome is the fairest approach; lifestyle is controversial and should be used with care.

Scenario 8: Patient with capacity refusing treatment

A diabetic patient with mental capacity refuses insulin, knowing they may die.

Answer: Autonomy allows a competent adult to refuse any treatment. Beneficence and non-maleficence would normally support the insulin. Explore why — depression? unaddressed side effects? financial reasons? Address the reasons. If capacity is confirmed and the refusal is informed, you respect it. Document carefully. Conclude: autonomy wins when capacity is confirmed and refusal is informed.

Scenario 9: Assisted dying

Discuss the arguments for and against legalising assisted dying.

Answer: For: autonomy (right to die with dignity); beneficence (ending suffering in terminal illness). Against: non-maleficence (risk of coercion of the vulnerable); justice concerns about who decides; slippery-slope concerns. UK current law (Suicide Act 1961 — assisting suicide is illegal) is under active review. Conclude: both sides have principled arguments; safeguards against coercion are the key design question if ever legalised.

Scenario 10: IVF funding

Should the NHS fund IVF? For whom? Up to what age?

Answer: Beneficence (infertility is a medical condition causing distress) competes with justice (NHS funds are finite; IVF is expensive per cycle and lower success at older ages). Current NICE guidance recommends 3 cycles for women under 40, limited cycles up to 42. Debate: should it be means-tested? Should couples with existing children receive funding? Conclude: evidence-based criteria (age, success rates, existing children) can balance justice and beneficence transparently.

How to prepare

Memorise the 4 pillars until you can say them in your sleep. Then practise applying them out loud to each scenario above — naming the pillar as you apply it. Follow this with 3–5 full mock interviews where a doctor can probe your reasoning with follow-up questions.

Want a doctor to practise these ethics scenarios with you live?

Our MMI course covers ethics scenarios with worked examples and includes a 1-to-1 mock with personal feedback. From £19.99 for 2027 entry.

See the MMI Course →

Frequently asked questions

What are the 4 pillars of medical ethics?

Autonomy (right to self-decide), beneficence (do good), non-maleficence (avoid harm) and justice (fair distribution of resources). Every ethics station is answered by applying each in turn and giving a reasoned conclusion.

How long should an ethics answer be at MMI?

90 seconds to 2 minutes. Name the dilemma, apply the 4 pillars in turn (30-40 seconds), acknowledge trade-offs, conclude. Leaving time for the interviewer to probe is important.

Can I just pick one pillar and argue it?

No. Interviewers mark harshly on one-sided answers. The strength of the 4-pillar framework is exactly that it forces you to weigh competing values. Always acknowledge the pillar you're arguing against.

Should I take a strong position or stay neutral?

Reasoned position, not neutral fence-sitting. Interviewers want to see that you can weigh evidence and conclude. End with something like: 'On balance, autonomy prevails here provided capacity is confirmed and alternatives have been explored.'

What if I don't know the real-world answer to a scenario?

That's fine. Ethics stations test reasoning, not recall. Say what you don't know ('I'm not sure what the current UK law says, but based on the 4 pillars I'd approach it as...') and reason from the framework.

Want help from a doctor?

Book a free consultation

30 minutes, no pressure, specific advice on your prep.

Book free consultation →